| Passing Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Completions | Johnny Unitas - Baltimore | Detroit | 9/29/1957 | Baltimore 24-13 | 25 |
| Most Passing Yards | Lamar McHan - Chicago C | Pittsburgh | 10/13/1957 | Pittsburgh 34-21 | 295 |
| Best Avg Yards Per Pass | Eddie LeBaron - Washington | Pittsburgh | 9/29/1957 | Washington 27-3 | 12.1 |
| Longest Completion | Tommy O'Connell - Cleveland | Pittsburgh | 11/10/1957 | Cleveland 28-24 | 65 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Completions | Baltimore | Detroit | 9/29/1957 | Baltimore 24-13 | 25 |
| Most Passing Yards | Chicago C | Pittsburgh | 10/13/1957 | Pittsburgh 34-21 | 295 |
| Best Avg Yards Per Pass | Washington | Pittsburgh | 9/29/1957 | Washington 27-3 | 12.1 |
| Longest Completion | Cleveland | Pittsburgh | 11/10/1957 | Cleveland 28-24 | 65 |
| Rushing Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Carries | Rick Casares - Chicago B | Los Angeles | 10/20/1957 | Los Angeles 35-17 | 27 |
| Most Rushing Yards | Rick Casares - Chicago B | San Francisco | 10/27/1957 | San Francisco 27-24 | 179 |
| Best Rushing Avg | Alan Ameche - Baltimore | Green Bay | 10/13/1957 | Baltimore 34-28 | 11.3 |
| Longest Carry | Ron Waller - Los Angeles | Green Bay | 12/8/1957 | Los Angeles 31-20 | 76 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Carries | Philadelphia | Pittsburgh | 12/1/1957 | Philadelphia 24-14 | 54 |
| Most Rushing Yards | Los Angeles | Green Bay | 12/8/1957 | Los Angeles 31-20 | 303 |
| Best Rushing Avg | Los Angeles | Green Bay | 12/8/1957 | Los Angeles 31-20 | 10.1 |
| Longest Carry | Los Angeles | Green Bay | 12/8/1957 | Los Angeles 31-20 | 76 |
| Receiving Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Receptions | Jim Mutscheller - Baltimore | Green Bay | 10/27/1957 | Baltimore 28-14 | 12 |
| Most Receiving Yards | Johnny Carson - Washington | Pittsburgh | 9/29/1957 | Washington 27-3 | 160 |
| Best Reception Yardage Avg | Johnny Carson - Washington | Pittsburgh | 9/29/1957 | Washington 27-3 | 32.0 |
| Longest Reception | Ray Renfro - Cleveland | Pittsburgh | 11/10/1957 | Cleveland 28-24 | 65 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Receptions | Baltimore | Detroit | 9/29/1957 | Baltimore 24-13 | 25 |
| Most Receiving Yards | Chicago C | Pittsburgh | 10/13/1957 | Pittsburgh 34-21 | 295 |
| Best Reception Yardage Avg | Philadelphia | Cleveland | 10/13/1957 | Philadelphia 23-7 | 23.0 |
| Longest Reception | Cleveland | Pittsburgh | 11/10/1957 | Cleveland 28-24 | 65 |
| Kickoff Return Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Returns | Joe Arenas - San Francisco | Detroit | 11/17/1957 | Detroit 40-10 | 7 |
| Best Return Yardage Avg | Jon Arnett - Los Angeles | Baltimore | 12/15/1957 | Los Angeles 37-24 | 59.5 |
| Longest Return | Jon Arnett - Los Angeles | San Francisco | 11/10/1957 | San Francisco 30-14 | 95 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Returns | San Francisco | Detroit | 11/17/1957 | Detroit 40-10 | 9 |
| Best Return Yardage Avg | Los Angeles | Baltimore | 12/15/1957 | Los Angeles 37-24 | 38.3 |
| Longest Return | Los Angeles | San Francisco | 11/10/1957 | San Francisco 30-14 | 95 |
| Punt Return Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Returns | Al Carmichael - Green Bay | Los Angeles | 11/17/1957 | Green Bay 38-7 | 6 |
| Best Return Yardage Avg | Ron Waller - Los Angeles | Cleveland | 11/24/1957 | Los Angeles 34-24 | 68.0 |
| Longest Return | Ron Waller - Los Angeles | Cleveland | 11/24/1957 | Los Angeles 34-24 | 68 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Returns | Pittsburgh | New York | 10/20/1957 | Pittsburgh 22-0 | 6 |
| Best Return Yardage Avg | Baltimore | Los Angeles | 12/1/1957 | Baltimore 34-13 | 49.0 |
| Longest Return | Los Angeles | Cleveland | 11/24/1957 | Los Angeles 34-24 | 68 |
| Defense Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Tackles | Matt Hazeltine - San Francisco | New York | 12/1/1957 | New York 33-10 | 20 |
| Sacks | Bob Gain - Cleveland | Pittsburgh | 10/5/1957 | Cleveland 23-6 | 3 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Tackles | Los Angeles | Chicago B | 11/3/1957 | Los Angeles 37-27 | 65 |
| Sacks | Chicago B | Chicago C | 12/8/1957 | Chicago B 26-3 | 11 |
| Interception Stats | |||||
| Player | |||||
| Stat | Player Name - Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Interceptions | Yale Lary - Detroit | San Francisco | 11/17/1957 | Detroit 40-10 | 3 |
| Best Interception Yardage Avg | Paul Miller - Los Angeles | Chicago B | 11/3/1957 | Los Angeles 37-27 | 83.0 |
| Longest Interception | Paul Miller - Los Angeles | Chicago B | 11/3/1957 | Los Angeles 37-27 | 83 |
| Team | |||||
| Stat | Team | Opponent | Date | Score | Value |
| Most Interceptions | New York | Philadelphia | 11/17/1957 | New York 30-3 | 6 |
| Best Interception Yardage Avg | Los Angeles | Chicago B | 11/3/1957 | Los Angeles 37-27 | 83.0 |
| Longest Interception | Los Angeles | Chicago B | 11/3/1957 | Los Angeles 37-27 | 83 |